Hello dear
Welcome to John's Pizzeria of Times Square
Nestled in the heart of New York City, John's Pizzeria of Times Square offers an unforgettable dining experience in a beautiful former church, adding a historic charm to your meal. Renowned for its delicious thin-crust pizza, the eatery delights with generous toppings and perfectly balanced flavors. Guests rave about the vibrant atmosphere, attentive service, and the opportunity to watch skilled chefs at work in the open kitchen. With quick service and a diverse menu that includes favorites like eggplant Parmesan and Italian margarita pizza, John's Pizzeria not only satisfies your cravings but creates lasting memories amid the bustling spirit of Times Square.
Signature Picks
Discover the highlights of the day
John's Garlic Rolls
US$18.00Spinach Salad
US$18.00Bruschetta
US$23.50
Hawaiian
US$28.25Buffalo Chicken Pizza
US$27.75Pizza Bianca
US$27.00
Margherita
$US$26.00Traditional
$US$21.75Soup of the Day - Seasonal
$US$9.50 Inside the Experience
John's Pizzeria of Times Square
Welcome to John's Pizzeria of Times Square, an iconic eatery nestled in the heart of New York City at 260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036. Known for its rich history and exceptional pizza, John's has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The moment you step inside this stunning restaurant, you are greeted by the warm ambiance and the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza permeating the air.
One of the standout features of John's is its unique location in a former church building, giving diners an atmosphere that is both lively and historic. The open kitchen concept adds an element of excitement as guests can watch the chefs craft their delicious creations right before their eyes. With an extensive menu, patrons have praised the exclusive thin-crust pizza that comes piled high with flavorful toppings and baked to perfection. The mozzarella is particularly noted as a highlight, bringing a rich creaminess that enhances every bite.
Customer reviews reflect the magical experience of dining at John's. Food enthusiasts rave about the Italian margarita pizza, the delectable cheese wedges, and the delightful shrimp fra diavolo. Visitors like Dee M and Bhushan Timla describe their experiences as unforgettable, often returning for a second meal out of sheer delight. The generous portions mean that taking home leftovers is not just possible, but a common practice among diners.
The service at John's is another highlight, with a friendly and attentive staff ensuring your visit is enjoyable. Reviews such as those from Christina McCleary and Mrs. Foster highlight the quick service and welcoming nature of the restaurant, even during peak times. While the atmosphere can be bustling, it never feels rushed, allowing guests to savor their meals in comfort.
Whether you are a pizza aficionado or simply looking for a memorable dining experience in Times Square, John's Pizzeria promises quality, flavor, and a unique setting that enhances your meal. From the rich heritage of the building to the fantastic food on your plate, every visit is a slice of New York’s culinary excellence. Don't miss out on this slice of heaven during your next visit to the Big Apple!
People talk
Guestbook
“ When we first arrived to the hotel, we asked one of the staff where to get the best pizza. He told us to go to John’s. We had no choice but to take his suggestion. Omgosh! As you can see I could barely get my phone out fast enough. The pizza was SO GOOD! The mozzarella was great, too! We loved it so much that we went back the next night. ”
“ Had explored it in internet before going to NYC, and it was worth to visit, fantastic eatery serving exclusive thin-crust pizza in Times Square. The atmosphere in this old church building with views of pizza ovens is amazing & the pizza was the best, very flavorful and perfect crust! Not only did we get to watch all our food get made, the toppings were heavy, sauce just right, and crust was slight crisp without falling over. Loved everything and will definitely be back. my favorite-must-stop pizzerias in NYC!! John’s Pizzeria of Times Square is a must-visit for pizza lovers. ”
“ Visited today at 5.30pm, and it was half empty. No queue, no issues, quick service. All was great! We were seated right in the middle, which was great, and had a brilliant view of everything going on. Ordered 2 large pizza for 3 of us and took lots home as they were huge! The food was quick and piping hot. No free refills on drinks, which is a shame, but we were given water upon arrival. Bill is slightly cheaper if you pay cash, around 5 bucks. Service was friendly and swift. Hit the spot after a busy day sightseeing with the family. Pizzas are around 34 dollars for a large, which is 8 slices. Highly recommend! ”
“ I enjoyed this place a lot. My only takeaway was our server gave me the wrong drink. Our server was pleasant and the ambiance was nice. The food was really good. We ordered the Italian margarita pizza, eggplant Parmesan pasta, and a salad. Sorry we don’t have more pics but the food was so good that we were only able to get this one lol ”
“ We went to John’s after getting in late from a delayed flight. We got right in and had drinks and food within 20 minutes. The servers were kind of quick but friendly. I enjoyed the pizza ovens being within view. Salad was good, pizza was delicious and the building is beautiful. I liked that it was busy but we didn’t feel rushed. The inside is warm and stuffy, so just be prepared for that. ”